For a side-by-side comparison of current personal firewall products, visit http://personal-firewall-software-review.toptenreviews.com/

From IBM's Site:

IBM Internet Security Systems has announced the End of Life for BlackICE PC Protection (formerly known as BlackICE Defender) and BlackICE Server Protection (formerly known as BlackICE Defender for Server). The End of Sale date for these products is September 19, 2007. You will not be able to purchase BlackICE products after this date. We will update and support BlackICE products until September 29, 2008. These products will not be supported after September 29th, 2008.

BlackICE PC Protection by Internet Security Systems prevents intruders from accessing your computer, and that's the main job for a firewall. BlackICE PC Protection lacks the extra features that our top-ranked products offer; these give you added protection from Trojans, adware and intrusive cookies (data stored on your computer by websites you visit).

Firewall Performance
Compare
6.3/10
Comodo Internet Security Complete
Agnitum Outpost Pro Firewall
Kaspersky Internet Security
ZoneAlarm Pro Firewall
Total Defense Internet Security Suite
Norton Internet Security
Bitdefender Internet Security
eScan Internet Security Suite
Norman Security Suite
McAfee Internet Security
9.2
9
8.6
3.4
3.1
9
9
5
4
3

BlackICE PC Protection has some unique features, including the ability to block or trust a visitor. This tool allows you to block for an hour, a day, a month or forever—we liked the flexibility this offered.

BlackICE has some powerful filtering features. You can specify the exact type and duration for each rule you create and you can make these rules specific to a given port on your computer. Without getting into much networking terminology, you can block a certain kind of message from entering or exiting a given location on your computer. This tool helps you fine tune your filtering. You can also turn application control and communication control on or off.

With BlackICE PC Protection, you can customize your firewall to record all of your computer's interactions. But to use these records (logs) to track data to its origin you'll need to buy trace file decoding software.

Additional Security Features
Compare
7.5/10
Comodo Internet Security Complete
Agnitum Outpost Pro Firewall
Kaspersky Internet Security
ZoneAlarm Pro Firewall
Total Defense Internet Security Suite
Norton Internet Security
Bitdefender Internet Security
eScan Internet Security Suite
Norman Security Suite
McAfee Internet Security
7.5
5
10
10
10
10
10
10
10
10

The BlackICE screen is not as simple to use as screens in other firewalls. BlackICE PC Protection has a good control panel and a useful history screen that lists past events and network traffic, but improvements would help push this firewall higher in the rankings.

Help and Support
Compare
8.8/10
Comodo Internet Security Complete
Agnitum Outpost Pro Firewall
Kaspersky Internet Security
ZoneAlarm Pro Firewall
Total Defense Internet Security Suite
Norton Internet Security
Bitdefender Internet Security
eScan Internet Security Suite
Norman Security Suite
McAfee Internet Security
10
5
7.5
10
10
10
8.8
7.5
5
7.5

BlackICE PC Protection did an excellent job keeping our identifying computer data stealth (hidden); viewers couldn't see our computer. The firewall also protected us from Trojans (dangerous software). BlackICE PC Protection failed to block an outsider's view of our browser information, however (the referrer test). This means that websites I visit can see what browser I'm using, what region I'm in, and last website I've visited, even with my firewall up and running.

BlackICE PC Protection Summary:
6.3/10

BlackICE PC Protection is a good firewall software program that needs control panel improvements to help novices take advantage of customization. With these improvements, BlackICE PC Protection has the potential to become a top contender.

BlackICE PC Protection provides many customizable features, enough to allow you to set up a small network if you want. But this would take an experienced computer user time to get right.

 

BlackICE PC Protection 3.6